CFTC Nominee Hearing Highlights Jurisdictional Dispute Over Prediction Markets
Published
The US Senate Agriculture Committee convened a hearing on November 17 to consider the nominations of Matthew Rowland and Nathan Anonick for CFTC commissioner positions.
MissedBlock Desk · 3 min read
The US Senate Agriculture Committee convened a hearing on November 17 to consider the nominations of Matthew Rowland and Nathan Anonick for CFTC commissioner positions. A central theme of the hearing was the ongoing jurisdictional dispute between the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and various states over the regulation of prediction markets and event contracts.
The nominees appeared before the committee as part of the process to fill vacant CFTC seats. The hearing highlighted the complexity of defining regulatory authority in these emerging markets, with differing views presented on federal versus state control. The confirmation of these nominees is time-sensitive, as unconfirmed nominations may need to be resubmitted to the new Congress convening in January.
Nominees’ Positions and Senate Concerns
Matthew Rowland stated that he understands the concerns raised by states and tribes regarding prediction markets and would seek to cooperate with them if appointed. Nathan Anonick expressed that the CFTC has discretion in determining if a contract violates public interest and intends to engage with stakeholders. Senator Tina Smith emphasized that the issue is legal, asserting that state law clearly grants jurisdiction over sports betting to state and tribal governments. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig, currently the only Republican commissioner, stated that the CFTC protects the integrity of regulated markets while not hindering responsible innovation.
Regulatory Framework and Proposed Changes
The core of the debate revolves around whether event contracts offered by platforms like Kalshi and Polymarket are federal derivatives under the CFTC’s purview or fall under state-level regulations. CFTC Rule 40.11, enacted in 2011, prohibits registered exchanges from listing event contracts related to gaming, terrorism, war, and assassination. The CFTC has proposed amendments to this rule, including definitions for ‘involve’ and ‘gaming,’ and establishing a 90-day review process for such contracts. Currently, approximately a dozen states are in legal disputes with the CFTC over jurisdiction, highlighting the significant financial implications related to tax revenue and licensing.
Implications of Confirmation and Future Outlook
If Rowland and Anonick are reported, the CFTC would return to a three-member size, potentially strengthening the legitimacy of its rulemaking and increasing the likelihood of finalizing the Rule 40.11 amendment. Conversely, a delay in confirmation could leave prediction market platforms in a state of legal uncertainty into 2027, potentially allowing state attorneys general to continue enforcement actions under existing laws.
The White House submitted the list of nominees to the Senate on November 12. The nominations must be reported before the new Congress begins in January; otherwise, they will need to be resubmitted. The current rule allows the commission to request exchanges to suspend trading during the 90-day review period. The CFTC and SEC have faced scrutiny for not having full five-member commissions due to partisan representation issues.
Several uncertainties remain regarding the final determination of jurisdiction over prediction markets and event contracts, the outcome of ongoing legal disputes between states and the CFTC, and the exact definitions within CFTC Rule 40.11. It is not definitively established whether prediction markets are classified solely under state law or as federal derivatives under CFTC jurisdiction, nor does the CFTC have formal approval over all such activities, and jurisdiction over sports betting is not solely vested with state governments.
Why This Matters
The hearing focused on the nominations of Matthew Rowland and Nathan Anonick for CFTC commissioner positions, with the final determination of jurisdiction over prediction markets and event contracts remaining a key uncertainty.
Broader Context
The nominations must be reported before the new Congress begins in January, otherwise the nominations must be resubmitted.
