Skip to content
Regulation & PolicyLatest

Coin Center Comments on SEC's Temporary Exemptive Relief

Published

Washington D.C.

MissedBlock Desk · 7 min read

Coin Center Comments on SEC's Temporary Exemptive Relief

Coin Center Urges SEC to Clarify Jurisdiction Over Open-Source Developers

Washington D.C. – Coin Center, an independent nonprofit research and advocacy organization focused on cryptocurrency policy, has submitted a formal comment to the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) urging the agency to clarify its jurisdiction over open-source software developers. The organization argues that the SEC’s recent “Innovation Exemption,” which provides temporary conditional exemptive relief for certain distributed ledger trading venues, should not inadvertently create regulatory burdens for those who develop and publish the underlying blockchain infrastructure.

Coin Center’s core mission is to foster a better understanding of cryptocurrency technologies and promote a regulatory environment that supports innovation on open blockchain networks. The organization achieves this through policy research, educating policymakers and the media, and advocating for sound public policy.

Protecting Foundational Innovators

In its comment, Coin Center acknowledges the SEC’s efforts to accommodate innovation in securities markets through the Innovation Exemption. However, the organization emphasizes the need for the Commission to clearly delineate the boundaries of its jurisdiction. Specifically, Coin Center contends that open-source development, which is crucial for the functioning of these markets, should not necessitate registration or exemptive relief simply because the resulting software could theoretically be used for securities transactions.

The organization proposes two key recommendations:

First, Coin Center calls for the SEC to issue formal guidance recognizing the First Amendment limitations on its authority over software publication and neutral blockchain infrastructure. This guidance should be supported by internal procedures that respect these limits during investigations and enforcement actions.

Second, the SEC should clarify that an independent developer does not become part of a Tokenized Securities Venue (TSV) merely because the venue later adopts the developer’s published software. These protections, Coin Center argues, should not be contingent on another party’s eligibility for or compliance with the Innovation Exemption.

Open-Source Development and First Amendment Rights

An effective step the SEC can take to foster innovation in the United States, according to Coin Center, is to publicly articulate that developing and publishing open-source software does not, in itself, require registration or exemptive relief under federal securities laws. While the Innovation Exemption may assist market participants in building securities businesses on open networks, these networks fundamentally rely on a more foundational group of innovators: developers who publish software that is inspectable, usable, modifiable, and improvable by anyone. These developers, Coin Center asserts, should not have to seek an exemption to exercise their First Amendment rights.

The SEC’s own justification for the Innovation Exemption highlights the importance of open development. The exemption cites “fairness, efficiency, and transparency” as regulatory objectives and requires smart contracts to be auditable and public, deployed on a “public, permissionless distributed ledger.” This openness, the Commission notes, allows participants and third parties to identify vulnerabilities and assess risks. Coin Center argues that since the SEC recognizes the benefits of open development for investor protection, it should provide a clear statement that publishing these tools does not transform developers into regulated intermediaries.

Drawing a Clear Boundary

Drawing on the insights of former Commissioner Hester Peirce, Coin Center reiterates that individuals who do nothing more than write open-source code for others to use should not be required to register with the SEC. Peirce’s statements have emphasized that an investor does not need an exemption to utilize permissionless smart contracts for peer-to-peer trading. Coin Center urges the Commission to adopt this distinction and provide developers with clear guidance that the SEC recognizes the limits of its jurisdiction, thereby preventing them from having to establish these limits at their own expense through enforcement actions.

Without such clarification, the Innovation Exemption could exacerbate the uncertainty faced by developers whose work enables blockchain innovation. A future Commission might interpret a business’s reliance on the exemption as grounds to question why an independent software developer did not seek similar relief. While the Innovation Exemption correctly states that reliance on it does not create a presumption that a TSV is an exchange, Coin Center argues it should also state that another party’s reliance on the exemption does not imply that developing or publishing the underlying software requires registration or relief.

Distinguishing Publication from Regulated Activities

The crucial distinction, Coin Center emphasizes, lies between publishing tools and undertaking regulated activities. Blockchain node clients, smart contracts, and user interfaces empower individuals to transact without relying on intermediaries. The mere publication of these tools, even if designed for securities transactions, does not establish that the developer operates a securities business. When a publisher engages in separate, potentially regulated activities, the SEC should identify those specific activities and the statutory basis for any resulting obligations. Formal guidance would acknowledge the constitutional limits already constraining the SEC’s authority and provide its staff with a framework for respecting them.

Coin Center’s April 2026 letter to the SEC outlined a framework for identifying this constitutional boundary through two principles: first, that the First Amendment protects the publication of software, data, technical designs, and neutral communication tools; and second, that registration requirements are only constitutionally permissible as prior restraints when an individual assumes control over another’s financial affairs in a traditional agency, custodial, advisory, or managerial capacity, exercising client-specific discretionary authority.

Clarifying the “Group of Persons” Definition

The Innovation Exemption addresses how a TSV may provide an Automated Market Maker (AMM) Liquidity Pool by exercising control over it, including through the deployment of an AMM smart contract. However, Coin Center points out that the exemption does not differentiate between deployment as part of operating a venue and the publication of a smart contract by an independent developer that an unrelated venue later adopts. This distinction is critical, as another party’s subsequent selection of publicly available software should not automatically make its publisher part of the venue’s “group of persons.”

While the SEC does clarify that a person solely performing the administrative act of encoding a smart contract to whitelist an AMM Liquidity Pool would not be providing such a pool, this clarification is narrowly focused. Coin Center warns that if an independent software developer merely deploys a smart contract for an AMM liquidity pool that a separate TSV subsequently selects and designates for its operations, the developer remains at risk of being encompassed into the “group of persons” because the exemption leaves this matter unresolved.

A Call for Lasting Clarity

The Innovation Exemption offers qualifying TSVs temporary relief from the definition of an exchange but does not resolve the status of independent software developers whose previously published or deployed smart contracts are later adopted by a TSV. Coin Center urges the SEC to clarify that such adoption does not make the developer part of the TSV’s “group of persons” without additional facts demonstrating the developer’s participation in operating the venue. This clarification should apply irrespective of whether the venue qualifies for or complies with the Innovation Exemption.

Coin Center implores the Commission to complement the Innovation Exemption with formal guidance that recognizes First Amendment limits on its authority over software publication and neutral blockchain infrastructure, supported by internal procedures that apply these limits during investigations and enforcement. This guidance should also address software designed for or used by TSVs and clarify that an unrelated TSV’s subsequent adoption of a developer’s already-published smart contract does not make the developer part of that venue. Protection for publication should not be dependent on temporary exemptive relief or another party’s compliance with its conditions. These steps, Coin Center concludes, would provide lasting clarity for software developers, foster innovation in the United States, and preserve the Commission’s authority over separately identifiable regulated conduct.

Coin Center Comments on SEC's Temporary Exemptive Relief · MissedBlock