Skip to content
Technology & InnovationLatest

Ethereum Glamsterdam Upgrade Stalls: EIPs 8037 & 8038 Threaten 15,000 Contracts

Published

Ethereum's upcoming major upgrade, Glamsterdam, is encountering significant hurdles before its launch, with concerns that it could break existing on-chain automated programs.

MissedBlock Desk · 3 min read

Ethereum Glamsterdam Upgrade Stalls: EIPs 8037 & 8038 Threaten 15,000 Contracts

Ethereum’s Glamsterdam Upgrade Faces Setback Amid Smart Contract Compatibility Concerns

Ethereum’s upcoming major upgrade, Glamsterdam, is encountering significant hurdles before its launch, with concerns that it could break existing on-chain automated programs. Marius van der Wijden, a developer at the Ethereum Foundation, estimated during a core developer meeting on Monday that up to 15,000 smart contracts could be affected. While this represents a small fraction of the network’s approximately 90 million contracts, the potential value at stake is in the hundreds of thousands of dollars.

The issue stems from two technical proposals, EIP-8037 and EIP-8038, which aim to alter how Ethereum charges for storing and retrieving data. Currently, every action a smart contract takes incurs a gas fee. EIP-8037 proposes to separately price the creation of new persistent state, such as deploying a contract or adding a storage slot, rather than bundling this cost into general execution gas.

This change would lead to a significant increase in costs. Deploying a new contract, for instance, would see its gas usage jump from 32,000 to approximately 183,600. Adding a new data storage slot would rise from 20,000 to around 97,920. The Foundation’s rationale for this price adjustment is to prevent rapid inflation of the underlying database as more activities are incorporated into each block in future upgrades.

However, many existing applications are built on the assumption of predictable costs or hardcoded gas amounts when calling other contracts. These assumptions would become invalid under the proposed changes.

To identify potentially affected applications, the Foundation commissioned external security firms for stress testing. Broad scans indicated up to 15,000 potentially vulnerable contracts. Additionally, auditing teams uncovered hundreds of potential risks. Security firm ChainSecurity reported 152 findings, about half of which overlapped with the Foundation’s internal research, totaling around 200 identified issues. A summary of these findings has been published on the Ethereum Magicians forum. Another firm, Dedaub, examined approximately 25,000 contracts with anomalous gas usage and flagged 70 medium-to-high risk issues, including 22 that the Foundation had initially overlooked.

These discoveries largely stem from two of the eight core technical assumptions that the Foundation alerted developers to on November 6th. The Foundation’s direct outreach to software teams also revealed three high-severity and at least 25 medium-severity defects, most of which are currently being addressed.

The findings also highlight a more fundamental debate: Ethereum has long touted the immutability of deployed contract code. However, changes to underlying rules can alter the behavior of the same contract, meaning the code remains unchanged, but its outcome differs.

Ansgar Dietrichs, a researcher at the Foundation and a co-author of the proposals, argued during the meeting for the upgrade to proceed, while acknowledging the need for clearer external communication from core engineers. Other participants warned that removing EIP-8037 outright would make it more difficult for developers to deploy large contracts, thereby weakening the upgrade’s intended security objectives.

The meeting on Monday did not yield a consensus. Compatibility issues have stalled testing progress since October, forcing engineers to postpone the planned launch of the Hoodi public testnet. Core developers are scheduled to reconvene on Thursday. The Foundation stated that Hoodi will remain paused until the errors are rectified, consequently leaving the Glamsterdam upgrade for the mainnet without a definitive release date.

Ethereum Glamsterdam Upgrade Stalls: EIPs 8037 & 8038 Threaten 15,000 Contracts · MissedBlock