Skip to content
Security & HacksLatest

Judge Acquits Brothers in Ethereum MEV Exploit Case

Published

A U.S.

MissedBlock Desk · 2 min read

Judge Acquits Brothers in Ethereum MEV Exploit Case

Judge Acquits Brothers in $25 Million Ethereum Exploit Case

A U.S. federal judge has acquitted two brothers accused of causing approximately $25 million in losses to automated trading bots in an Ethereum MEV (Maximal Extractable Value) exploit case. The pivotal factor in the ruling was that a transaction relay released data without verifying two critical fields within a block header.

U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke on November 16, 2026, cleared Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, stating that prosecutors failed to demonstrate the material misrepresentation necessary to prove wire fraud. This decision marks the conclusion of the government’s inaugural criminal prosecution focused on an Ethereum MEV exploit.

The alleged scheme occurred in April 2023. Prosecutors contended that the brothers deployed eight “bait” transactions to lure sandwich-trading bots, a type of automated trading that profits by executing trades around other users’ orders.

When the brothers’ validator received a proposed block via the Ultrasound relay, it signed a block header with two essential fields set to zero. These zeroed values indicated a block that could not be valid. However, the relay proceeded to release the block’s transaction contents without verification. This allowed the brothers to construct an alternative block and substitute the bait transactions with trades designed to disadvantage the bots.

The operation resulted in an estimated $25 million in losses for the bots within approximately 12 seconds.

The judge determined that prosecutors had not established that the disputed fields influenced the relay’s decision to release the block. Without this causal link, the alleged false information could not constitute the material misrepresentation required for a wire fraud conviction.

Judge Clarke also dismissed the argument that the bait transactions guaranteed bots a specific execution order. The public mempool of the Ethereum network does not provide assurances for the inclusion or sequential execution of pending transactions.

The brothers were indicted in May 2024. Their initial trial concluded in a mistrial in November 2025 when the jury could not reach a unanimous verdict.

The acquittal on November 16 encompassed charges of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, and conspiracy to commit money laundering.

While this ruling does not legitimize all MEV strategies or exploits, the decision in this Ethereum MEV exploit case draws a clear line between questionable trading practices and the specific deceptive intent that prosecutors must prove in criminal fraud cases.

Judge Acquits Brothers in Ethereum MEV Exploit Case · MissedBlock