Skip to content
Technology & InnovationLatest

Quantum-Resistant Cryptography Transition Poses Significant Performance and Cost Challenges for Blockchains

Published

The transition to quantum-resistant cryptography (PQC) could impose substantial performance degradation and increased costs on public blockchains, particularly Layer 1 networks, according to a report by the International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO).

MissedBlock Desk · 3 min read

Quantum-Resistant Cryptography Transition Poses Significant Performance and Cost Challenges for Blockchains

The transition to quantum-resistant cryptography (PQC) could impose substantial performance degradation and increased costs on public blockchains, particularly Layer 1 networks, according to a report by the International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO). The adoption of new cryptographic signatures, such as NIST-standardized ML-DSA-44, will lead to significantly larger data requirements, potentially slowing transaction processing, increasing network congestion, and driving up fees.

Data Burden on Layer 1 Networks

Commonly used elliptic curve cryptography (ECC) signatures are typically 64 bytes. In contrast, signatures generated by the ML-DSA-44 scheme are approximately 2,420 bytes, representing an increase of 35 to 40 times. This dramatic rise in data size could place considerable pressure on the capacity of Layer 1 networks, where every transaction must be processed, validated, and transmitted across the network. Larger signatures mean more data traveling through the system, greater storage requirements for nodes, and potentially slower block propagation. IOSCO pointed to evidence from Solana’s quantum-resistant testnet, where replacing ECC signatures with post-quantum alternatives resulted in an approximately 90% decline in throughput.

Decentralized Upgrade Complexities

Beyond performance, the migration to PQC necessitates protocol-level changes, including hard forks, which are complex undertakings for decentralized systems. Unlike conventional financial systems where a central operator can implement software updates, decentralized blockchains rely on thousands of independent validators and node operators to coordinate upgrades. This process could be slow and uneven, potentially leaving some accounts, smart contracts, and assets dependent on quantum-vulnerable keys even after PQC features have been introduced elsewhere.

Layer 2 Dependencies and Rollup Nuances

Layer 2 networks, such as optimistic rollups and zero-knowledge rollups, also face challenges. While these systems process transactions off-chain to improve speed and reduce the burden on their underlying Layer 1 networks, they remain dependent on their host chains for critical security functions, including settlement, bridges, data availability, and verification. Therefore, adopting PQC at the Layer 2 level alone may not be sufficient if essential components on the underlying Layer 1 remain vulnerable. Many existing SNARK-based systems, which often rely on ECC, may require modification or replacement. STARK-based systems, which primarily use hash-based cryptography, are considered more resistant to quantum attacks, though their security depends on appropriate parameters and the strength of underlying hash functions.

Uncertainties Remain

The report highlights several uncertainties surrounding this transition. These include the exact extent of performance degradation across different Layer 1 networks, the feasibility and timeline for coordinating hard forks in decentralized environments, and the specific effort required to modify or replace existing cryptographic systems like SNARKs. The precise parameters and strength of hash functions for STARK-based systems also remain a point of consideration.

Why This Matters

The materials describe a narrow update: A report by IOSCO suggests that adopting quantum-resistant cryptography (PQC) signatures, such as ML-DSA-44, in place of current elliptic curve cryptography (ECC) signatures will lead to larger data requirements (35-40x larger), increased transaction processing times, network congestion, and higher fees on public blockchains, especially Layer 1 networks. The exact extent of performance degradation across different L1 networks.

Broader Context

Source materials place the factual news in this context: The transition to quantum-resistant cryptography could come at a high cost to the performance of public blockchains, particularly Layer 1 networks such as Ethereum, Solana and Tron, according to a report by the International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO).

Quantum-Resistant Cryptography Transition Poses Significant Performance and Cost Challenges for Blockchains · MissedBlock