Tether Cites "The Big Short" in S&P Reserve Risk Jab
Published
S&P Global Ratings has maintained Tether's USDt stablecoin at the lowest possible score on its stability scale, citing an increasing proportion of riskier assets within the token's reserves.
MissedBlock Desk · 3 min read
S&P Global Ratings has maintained Tether’s USDt stablecoin at the lowest possible score on its stability scale, citing an increasing proportion of riskier assets within the token’s reserves.
Stablecoin Stability Assessment Unchanged
In a report released November 18, S&P assigned USDt a score of 5 (weak) for its ability to maintain its dollar peg. This assessment remains unchanged from November 2025. The agency noted that its lowest available score is 5, meaning no further downward adjustment was possible.
As of September 30, higher-risk holdings such as gold, Bitcoin (BTC), public equities, secured loans, and corporate bonds constituted 28% of USDt in circulation, an increase from 24% a year prior. S&P warned in its report that “a significant drop in the value of these assets could lead to USDT being undercollateralized.”
Tether, however, pushed back against the assessment, stating, “The problem is S&P’s framework, not our reserves.” The company referenced the 2008 financial crisis, as depicted in the film The Big Short, to suggest that traditional financial systems have inherent flaws.
Reserve Holdings and Regulatory Scrutiny
Tether’s reserve report for September 30, attested by BDO, indicated approximately $191.5 billion in assets against $183.5 billion in liabilities, resulting in an excess of roughly $7.95 billion. S&P acknowledged these excess assets but reiterated that its assessment could not be lowered further.
Among the additional weaknesses identified by S&P was the regulatory environment in El Salvador, where Tether relocated in January 2025. The report highlighted that El Salvador’s National Commission of Digital Assets (CNAD), the regulatory body overseeing Tether in the country, mandates that 70% of reserves be held in assets liquid within 30 days. Tether stated that it considers this framework “broad,” permitting the inclusion of assets with relatively higher risk, such as gold, BTC, and loans.
The S&P report also pointed to the absence of a requirement to segregate reserve assets, a practice expected by regulators in the U.S. and Europe. The lack of publicly available information regarding segregation, the report stated, prevents insight into how these assets are protected from broader corporate risks.
Audit and Transparency Concerns
In August 2026, KPMG confirmed it had issued an unqualified opinion on Tether’s 2025 accounts, marking the company’s first “full independent audit.” Tether emphasized that this audit supported its financial statements.
However, S&P noted that the audited statements and the auditor’s report have not been published, limiting its ability to verify the underlying information. Furthermore, S&P stated that reserve reports do not identify the custodians and counterparties holding Tether’s assets. The agency also pointed out that attestations are provided quarterly, whereas other stablecoins typically report monthly.
At the time of S&P’s initial downgrade in 2025, Tether had disputed the outcome. CEO Paolo Ardoino had previously stated on X, “we wear your loathing with pride,” suggesting that past financial collapses served as “proof” of the inadequacy of traditional systems.
Despite the unchanged stability rating, S&P concluded its November 18 report by acknowledging that Tether has maintained a strong record of price stability, particularly over the past 12 months.
